Plush vs Firm Mattresses: What You Should Know

Vincent DeFazio • June 18, 2024
0 minute read
Firm vs plush mattress

There’s a lot of questions to ask yourself when looking for a mattress, but one of the most important is do you want a plush or firm mattress? You may only want to consider other important factors, including the size and cost of the mattress, after you have determined your ideal firmness levels for your mattress.


What Are the Key Differences Between a Plush and Firm Mattress?


A common misconception among mattress shoppers is that firm mattresses have fewer comfort layers than plush mattresses. Firm mattresses don’t necessarily have fewer layers, but they may have thinner ones. This ensures they provide ample support without a lot of cushioning or give. Plush mattresses, on the other hand, have thick, cushioned layers that provide a plump sleeping surface. Put simply, this isn’t a matter of hard versus soft but rather whether you prefer a sturdy mattress or a more pliable and giving one.

 

Weight also isn’t necessarily a differentiating factor. The coils in firm mattresses and the additional cushioned layers in plush mattresses can make both difficult to move or flip over. If having a lightweight mattress is important to you, such as if you’re expecting to need to move the mattress frequently, an InnerSpring mattress will be the easiest to move. These mattresses are highly durable, so you don’t have to worry about damaging them in transit, and they are available in an array of firmness levels, including many that will appeal to those who want a middle-ground option when deciding between firm and plush.


 

Pros and Cons of Plush Mattresses


Pros

  • Comfortable: The biggest benefit of a plush mattress is its enhanced comfort, as its soft surface creates a lush, cushioned feel that cradles you and can make sleep more enjoyable.


  • Customization: Plush mattresses are highly customizable. Pillow top and plush-top mattresses in particular can be made with a variety of supportive materials, including InnerSpring and latex. Twilight Bedding allows shoppers to personalize their mattress to meet their unique sleeping needs.


  • Balanced Support: Despite the soft surface, most plush mattresses provide good underlying support. Only memory foam doesn’t, as many report waking up in the middle of the night to find themselves sinking into the mattress.

 

Cons


  • Heat Retention: The extra padding can hinder the mattress’s breathability, making it more likely to retain heat and create a warm sleeping surface that some may find uncomfortable.


  • Maintenance: While some plush mattresses may require less maintenance, the softer top may be more high-maintenance than other mattresses, as their additional padding can require special care to preserve their quality.


 

Who Should Buy a Plush Mattress?

 

Plush mattresses are ideal for side sleepers and those trying to alleviate pressure on their shoulders and hips, like older adults. A soft sleeping surface can soothe discomfort and provide a luxurious, cradling sensation.

 

Pros and Cons of Firm Mattresses


Pros


  • Proper Spinal Alignment: Firm mattresses provide strong underlying support that helps maintain proper spinal alignment, reducing the risk of back pain for those who sleep on their backs.


  • Cooler Sleeping Surface: Because they have less padding, firm mattresses are less likely to retain heat, creating a temperature-neutral sleeping surface.


  • Motion Isolation: Since they have less give, firm mattresses offer superior motion isolation, reducing motion transfer that can help you and your partner sleep better even if one of you tosses and turns in their sleep.

 

Cons


  • Rigid: Firm mattresses’ stiff sleeping surface may be uncomfortable for some and can exert pressure on your shoulders and hips, especially if you sleep on your side or if you weigh under 130 lbs.


  • Initial Adjustment: It can be harder to break in a firm mattress than a soft mattress, potentially leading to a slightly uncomfortable adjustment period.

 

Who Should Buy a Firm Mattress?

 

Firm mattresses will be ideal for those who sleep on their stomach or back and need help maintaining proper spinal alignment as well as those who easily overheat while trying to sleep. Those who weigh more than 230 lbs may also enjoy a firm mattress, as the pushback a firm mattress provides will prevent sinking while offering more of a cradling sensation than a plush mattress.



 

Buy a High-Quality Firm or Plush Mattress From Local Manufacturers Who’ve Been Producing Mattresses for Over 30 Years

 

As a factory-direct, family-owned company, the team at Twilight Bedding takes great pride in producing hand-made mattresses that have been optimized to provide our customers with reliably great sleep every night – all at a lower price than our competitors.

 

Learn more about our vast inventory of plush and firm mattresses, including luxury quality latex and InnerSpring mattresses, by calling our Spokane Valley Showroom at (509) 926-2333 or our North Spokane Showroom at (509) 413-2431, or visit us today.

By Vincent DeFazio May 21, 2025
Sleep is a vital part of childhood growth, development, mood and academic performance. While it may seem convenient or cost-effective to pass down a used mattress from an older sibling or relative, the truth is that hand-me-down mattresses may do more harm than good for your child’s health and sleep quality. At Twilight Bedding, we know families are always looking for smart ways to save money, but cutting corners on your child’s sleep setup can lead to long-term consequences. Mattresses Break Down Over Time  Even high-quality mattresses are not built to last forever. Over years of use, materials like foam, coils and padding begin to break down, losing their ability to provide proper support and alignment. An old mattress that has already conformed to someone else’s body is unlikely to offer the spinal support growing kids and teens need. Children and teenagers are constantly developing. Their spines, muscles and joints need a mattress that promotes healthy alignment and adapts to their growing bodies. A sagging or worn-out mattress can contribute to poor posture, disrupted sleep and even back pain in younger sleepers. Hygiene and Allergens Are a Real Concern Another key reason to skip the hand-me-down mattress? Hygiene. Older mattresses can harbor years of built-up dust, allergens, dead skin cells, sweat, bacteria and even mold, especially if they’ve been stored improperly. Young sleepers are more vulnerable to allergens and respiratory issues, which can be made worse by sleeping on a used mattress. If your child suffers from allergies or asthma, a secondhand bed could quietly be making things worse night after night. And while it may not be pleasant to think about, bed bugs or dust mites are also a risk with used mattresses, especially if they’ve changed hands or locations multiple times. Buying new helps you avoid all these potential health hazards. Lack of Support Affects More Than Just Sleep Sleep quality is just as important as the number of hours spent in bed. If a mattress doesn’t support your child properly, it can lead to tossing and turning, body aches and even a lack of deep, restorative sleep. This has a direct impact on: Mood and emotional regulation School performance and focus Physical development and immune function Behavior and energy levels Teens, in particular, are going through rapid physical and hormonal changes that require consistent, quality rest. Giving them a mattress that’s past its prime can hinder both their physical and emotional well-being. One Size Does Not Fit All Just because a mattress worked for one person doesn’t mean it will work for someone else. Factors like weight, sleep position and sensitivity vary significantly between individuals. Your growing child or teen may need something firmer, softer or cooler than the person who used the mattress before them. When you buy new, you can choose the right size (Twin XL, Full, etc.), firmness and materials that best support your child’s current stage of development and continues to serve them well for years to come. A New Mattress is an Investment in Their Future Think of a mattress like you would a pair of shoes. You wouldn’t hand down worn-out shoes and expect them to support someone through miles of running or walking. A mattress is no different. I's a foundation for healthy rest, which affects every part of your child’s life. At Twilight Bedding, we carry a full range of affordable, high-quality mattresses perfect for kids, teens and college-bound young adults. Whether you’re shopping for a first “big kid” bed, upgrading for a growth spurt or preparing for a dorm room, we’re here to help. We Make It Easy for Families to Shop Smart We understand that raising kids comes with lots of expenses, which is why we offer: A variety of mattresses at different price points Long-lasting, child- and teen-friendly options that won’t wear out quickly In-store guidance from sleep specialists who understand what growing bodies need Financing options to make it even easier to invest in better sleep Stop by One of Our Spokane Showrooms and Find the Right Mattress for Your Child Your child deserves more than someone else’s leftovers when it comes to sleep. Let us help you find a mattress that promotes better health, better sleep and a better future. You can learn more by calling our North Spokane location at (509) 413-2431 for or our Spokane Valley showroom at (509) 926-2333.
By Vincent DeFazio May 21, 2025
Discover the benefits of buying a mattress locally at Twilight Bedding in Spokane. Test comfort firsthand, get expert advice, and enjoy immediate delivery options.
By Vincent DeFazio May 14, 2025
Avoid the common mattress shopping mistakes people regret after it’s too late. Twilight Bedding in Spokane, WA shares expert tips to help you choose right the first time.
Show More